17
« Last post by CmdrJoe on February 06, 2026, 05:25:35 pm »
I just want to be clear about how I use AI on HoloNet Audio, as opposed to my chief complaint above, about it being used completely in fanfilms, etc.
To be clear, I NEVER fully use AI in the audio I produce on here. I use it as a TOOL only. I have been criticized so much for it on Facebook that I've had to retreat from using my own Facebook account for a while, logging in only as my page, instead of as myself. It's really come down to that.
First of all, HoloNet Audio was founded in February 2013. Thirteen years ago this month. It succeeded Dark Empire Radio (founded in February 2010), on which I did largely the same thing. So, I've been doing this for 16 years, long before the usage of AI became available like it is now. If AI is banned or regulated, it won't affect me at all; I started using artificial intelligence tools around the same time this forum was created, to assist me with what I do.
• I've used AI voices, in addition to human voices, my own included, as needed.
• I've used AI background music, in addition to purchased royalty-free music.
• I've used AI artwork as a thumbnail to help visualize the accompanying audio track, and it is also included in any posted fanfiction PDF associated with that audio track.
• Lastly, as has happened on this forum, I believe it can be used to help others with creative writing difficulties.
In short, I understand that AI has its controversial drawbacks, but I can only speak of how I have used it constructively, to assist me with my audio hobby and to encourage others with learning or writing difficulties to formulate grammatical syntax, etc. USE IT AS A TOOL, NOT TO DO YOUR WORK FOR YOU!
That has been and always will be the policy here. If the usage of AI is ever regulated or outlawed, it will not take away from the many years of audio I've put together already, and I can easily revert back to that without using AI. It has only helped me, not harmed anyone.
All that said, on Facebook recently, I was in an involuntary debate with Bryan, another Star Wars podcast presenter who openly stated that if anyone posts "AI garbage" on his timeline, he would block them. I completely understand his position. I commented about my mixed feelings on AI, as I've outlined already in this thread, stating that despite its shortcomings, it can be used for good, as I have used it.
Bryan replied that all AI is bad, and that as a writer and a filmmaker, AI has stolen intellectual property from him and others, and heavily damages the environment. I did not dispute his point, and stated that his opinion is certainly valid. I even encouraged him to prove the loss done to him and join any lawsuits currently in progress against AI; I certainly would if I were in that position.
But, he could not agree to disagree, like adults, as I offered. His army of friends on FB continually used metaphorical analogies to equate the usage of AI with stealing, and how it is completely unethical to use. I tried to indicate that my opinion on the matter varies from theirs, and that would not change. If the tool exists as an option for me to use, then I am likely to use it if it helps me, as I have done. Again, I do not let artificial intelligence do my work for me! I have spent, and continue to spend many long hours of my free time on this podcast, and now this community, trying to grow something I love. I don't need AI for that. But if it helps me put together a believable and entertaining fanfiction podcast, if it helps me to reach out charitably and help other people, then I will use it. As a tool. Nothing more than that.
Needless to say, the condescension toward me did not cease, and I had to block Bryan, and his Star Wars podcast page, on the eve of Star Wars Podcast Day. I felt very humiliated, low, and outright assaulted to my core after that. I will defend HoloNet Audio, and the work I have done over the years, with or without the help of AI, from others that would judge me or the work I have done, without even having listened to HoloNet Audio themselves, or having looked at this forum. Plus, the very platform Bryan and his friends were preaching to me on, Facebook, has embraced and utilized AI way more than I certainly have. I see that as hypocrisy, pure and simple!
I apologize for another long post. But this explains my self-imposed exile from social media for now. This forum is my home, MY social media. I welcome those who support what I do on here. I have no patience for hypocrites and others who would judge me or what I've done, especially after having spent so much time, money, and energy over the years. I love putting together quality family-friendly fanfiction audio stories. Again, I don't need AI, but as a tool, it's recently helped. End of discussion.
I will keep this thread open for now, but if there is any disrespect, disparaging remarks, or condescension of any kind on this thread about this issue, then I will lock this thread. I won't put up with anymore debate, especially here on this forum. We are here to have fun and enjoy ourselves as fans of STAR WARS and STAR TREK. If you disagree with me about AI, you don't have to be here. I agree it's probably bad for the environment, and I limit my usage of it accordingly. But be respectful and don't attack me if I've utilized it as an available tool to help me help others (i.e., the FANFIC charity project).